Holiday orders are open. Order by 11/21 for Thanksgiving, 12/19 for Holiday.Order now
Illinois St. Food Emporium
← ALL OPENINGS

CAREERS

General Manager

TYPE
Full-time
PAY
$60,000 – $80,000 a year, plus metric-based incentives
LOCATION
5550 N Illinois St, Indianapolis
BENEFITS
Open to discuss

Illinois Street Food Emporium is a scratch bakery, deli and breakfast and lunch counter on North Illinois Street, with a catering business, a wholesale line and a prepared foods retail program running alongside it. Six days a week, one roof, four businesses that all have to work at the same time.

We are hiring a General Manager to own that operation end to end. Not to supervise it. To own it.

Right now the owner carries this role on top of everything else. The point of this hire is that he stops carrying it. The person who takes this job becomes the one the buck stops with: the guest at the counter, the bread coming out right, the catering order that leaves at 6am, the labor line, the health inspection, the shift nobody showed up for. There is no one above you absorbing those problems. That is the job.

What you will own

  • The counter and the floor. Service speed, the state of the room, a case that still looks worth buying from at 2pm, and a team that knows the menu. You are on the floor during peak service.
  • The bakery and the kitchen. Production schedules, prep, recipes and portioning, waste and yield, and the handoff from the overnight bake to the morning counter. You do not need to be the baker. You do need to know when the product has slipped.
  • Catering. Our highest margin line and the one with the least room for error. Quoting, production planning, staffing, on-time delivery, follow-up, and growing the repeat accounts.
  • Wholesale and freezer. Standing orders that get filled on schedule no matter how busy the counter is. Accounts, pricing, reliability.
  • The numbers. Food cost, paper, labor, waste, voids and comps. You get a weekly flash report and a monthly P&L, and you are expected to read them, explain the variances and fix them before next month looks the same.
  • The team. Around 30 people across bakery, kitchen, counter and catering. Hiring, onboarding, scheduling, training, performance, and the hard conversations.
  • Compliance. Marion County health code, food safety, allergens, temperature logs, equipment, and our beer and wine license. You own the inspection result.

What success looks like

  • Prime cost under 65% of sales and moving toward 60%, with food, paper and labor all held to target.
  • Labor scheduled to forecast, with overtime treated as a planning failure rather than a cost of doing business.
  • Catering growing year over year, measured by repeat accounts rather than one-off events.
  • A clean health inspection every time, with no repeat findings.
  • Turnover falling, shifts covered without a scramble, and people promoted from inside.
  • Average ticket rising through what the team actually offers at the counter, not through price alone.

You will not be handed all of this at full speed in week one. You will own all of it by month three.

How we work

You come with the answer, not the question. When something breaks we want to hear what happened, what you did, and what you need from us.

The numbers are the conversation. "It felt busy" is not a report. If labor ran over, you should know which shift before anyone asks.

Hospitality is the product. People can buy bread and sandwiches in a dozen other places. What they cannot get elsewhere is the feeling of being somewhere glad they came. You set that by being on the floor.

Craft is worth defending. We bake from scratch. It costs more and takes longer and we are not looking to be talked out of it.

Clean is not negotiable. Health code is the floor, not the goal. You set the standard by what you walk past without fixing.

Bad news travels early. Nobody here gets in trouble for surfacing a problem. People lose trust by sitting on one.

What you bring

  • Five or more years running a restaurant, bakery, deli, catering operation or food hall concept, with full accountability for the result.
  • A P&L you have actually owned. You can name a prime cost you moved, how you moved it, and what it cost you.
  • Hands-on scheduling and labor management against a sales forecast.
  • Food safety certification and real familiarity with county health inspection, or the ability to certify quickly.
  • Catering experience, or a track record of learning a new line fast and owning it.
  • Willingness to work the hours the business keeps. Bakery production starts early, catering happens on weekends, and this is not a nine to five.

Helpful but not required: scratch or production baking, wholesale account management, Toast, and experience taking a business from breaking even to genuinely profitable.

What this job is not

  • Not a step up from assistant manager. The scope is the whole operation from day one.
  • Not a corporate or fast food role. No head office playbook, no regional support. You will write the systems that do not exist yet.
  • Not an office job. If you want to manage from behind a laptop, this will make you unhappy.

Details

Location: 5550 N. Illinois St., Indianapolis. Single site, on site.

Schedule: Monday through Saturday operating days. Early starts and some weekends.

Reports to: the owner, as an operating partner rather than a supervised manager.